Navigating the Landscape of Solar Leasing: A Deep Dive into Mineral and Surface Rights

In recent times, the world has been shifting towards renewable energy sources, and solar power has emerged as a leading contender. As the sector expands, more landowners are approached with solar leasing proposals. However, understanding the complexities of mineral servitude laws, particularly in the U.S., and the interplay with surface rights is critical for those considering such proposals. This article delves into these aspects, with a special focus on oil and gas leasing and the importance of securing surface rights for solar installations.


Understanding the Intricacies of Mineral and Surface Rights

In the realm of property rights, it’s pivotal to understand the distinction between surface and mineral rights. Owning the surface rights of a parcel of land doesn’t necessarily imply ownership of the minerals underneath it. This can be a surprising revelation for landowners looking to monetize their property through an oil and gas lease or a solar lease.


Surface Rights and Mineral Rights: A Complex Relationship

In regions where drilling, mining, or wind energy operations are commonplace, it’s not unusual for ownership rights to be severed. This means that the surface estate can be owned separately from the mineral estate. For instance, if an individual sells only the surface rights to a property while retaining the mineral rights, they hold the power to sign an oil and gas lease. The surface rights, in most states, are secondary to these mineral rights.

A careful examination of your property deed may not always clarify whether you own the mineral rights. A procedure known as running title is the definitive way to ascertain this. This process involves a qualified individual examining the mineral title to determine if the mineral rights have been severed through a prior mineral conveyance.

The Accommodation Doctrine: Balancing Surface and Mineral Rights

The Accommodation Doctrine is a legal principle adopted by many oil and gas producing states to balance the rights of surface owners with the interests of mineral owners. This doctrine recognizes that one parcel of land can possess multiple ownership estates. Consequently, the surface owner might not own the oil, gas, or other minerals beneath the surface.

Traditionally, the mineral estate is considered “dominant” to the surface estate. This dominance is rooted in the belief that ownership of minerals would be meaningless if the mineral owner could not access and extract those resources through the surface. However, the Accommodation Doctrine, in a landmark decision, shifted the balance significantly back towards equilibrium.

Solar Leasing: A New Frontier in Energy Production

With the Inflation Reduction Act incentivizing the adoption of solar power, solar leasing is expected to gain increased attention. A typical commercial solar lease involves an external party negotiating with a landowner to place solar panels and other necessary infrastructure on their property for a significant period, often 25-35 years. These leases can be complex and necessitate careful review by an experienced attorney.

Key Clauses in Solar Leases

Solar leases can vary in their specifics, but some common clauses demand careful consideration. For instance, signing a solar lease doesn’t guarantee the construction of a solar project. The solar company has the option to go forward with the project, but they may choose not to proceed. The landowner is typically obligated to grant them property access and refrain from signing any potentially interfering agreements during an initial period.

Another critical concern is income from the solar lease. Rental rates can vary dramatically, so researching current rates is crucial before signing a solar lease. Additionally, considering how your rental rate will increase over time is essential due to the longevity of these agreements.

Solar Power: The Driving Forces

Solar power is gaining momentum due to several factors, including reduced costs, growing adoption rates, smaller carbon footprints, and government mandates. The market price of solar energy has dropped significantly over the past decade, making it one of the cheapest ways to generate energy. Furthermore, as the consequences of climate change become more evident, there is increasing social and political pressure to reduce CO2 production, prompting a shift towards renewable energy resources like solar power.

Securing Surface Rights for Solar Installations

Securing surface rights is a crucial step in setting up a solar installation. Notably, in regions where energy operations such as drilling or mining are prevalent, securing these rights can be a complex process. Making sure that you’ve done proper title due diligence is imperative to avoid potential pitfalls and repercussions if the title fails.

With solar power emerging as a viable and sustainable energy source, solar leasing has become an increasingly relevant topic for landowners. Navigating the complexities of mineral and surface rights, along with the intricacies of leasing agreements, requires a thorough understanding of the legal landscape and potential pitfalls. Ensuring proper due diligence and securing surface rights are vital steps in this process.

As we move towards a more sustainable future, understanding these aspects can help landowners make informed decisions and contribute to the global effort for renewable energy.


Please be advised that this blog is not written by an attorney and should not be construed as legal advice. The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to address specific legal issues or situations.

While we strive to ensure the accuracy and currency of the content, laws and regulations may vary and change over time. Therefore, it is crucial to consult with a qualified attorney or legal professional for personalized advice tailored to your individual circumstances.



Office Hours

Mon-Fri – 9:00 am to 5:00 pm

Contact Info

2441 High Timbers Dr.

Suite 300

The Woodlands, TX 77380



Copyright © 2024 P&P Oil & Gas Solutions, LLC All Rights Reserved.